Coffee in Garden City

Flavorful coffee at The Bagels in Garden City, NY includes brewed and iced drinks, with pickup available for your next cup.

Order online

Coffee to Try

Flavored Coffee

Flavored coffee comes in a required small or large size.

Large Hazelnut Flavored Coffee$3.25Large brewed coffee with hazelnut flavor, available with your choice of milk and sweetener.
Small French Vanilla Flavored Coffee$2.50Small brewed coffee with French vanilla flavor, available with your choice of milk and sweetener.

“Great place for breakfast and lunch! Love their flavored coffee choices!”

Iced Flavored Coffee

Iced coffee with optional flavor choices and a required size selection.

“The banana iced coffee is my favorite! The service is always prompt and polite and they have the best bagels on the block.”

Cappuccino

$2.99+

Espresso with steamed milk and foam makes this classic coffee drink.

“I love the iced coffee. It has real iced coffee cubes. Don’t miss out.”

Decaf Coffee

$2.50+

Decaffeinated coffee comes in a required small or large size.

“The Bagels has the BEST iced coffee not just because the coffee is fresh but because the ice cubes are made of coffee- your beverage is never watered down! Great service, nice staff and delicious salads! Their Too Good To Go bags are also very generous!”

Iced Coffee

$3.50+

Brewed coffee over ice, with a required medium or large size.

“We had an event at the office and ask for The Bagels to cater. They did an awesome job!! The bagels were fresh. The fruit were sweet. The french toast was delicious!! The order was ready on time. Let me not forget to add that the Iced Coffee with the Iced Coffee ice cubes...no words!! Thank you for the excellent work!! My staff was very happy and full :)”

Iced Decaf

$3.50+

Iced decaffeinated coffee, sized medium or large, with optional add-ins.

“Love this spot for bagels! Always so fresh and so yummy! And their iced coffee has coffee cubes so it’s never watered down when it melts!”

Regular Coffee

$2.50+

Brewed coffee with a required choice of small or large size.

“Excellent iced coffee &”

A Taste of The Bagels

At The Bagels, coffee ranges from the freshly brewed Regular Coffee to Flavored Coffee with French vanilla or hazelnut. Iced Coffee features brewed coffee served over ice for a cold drink.

Cappuccino has a rich, smooth profile and comes in small or large sizes. Decaf Coffee offers oat milk or half & half options, while Iced Decaf is decaffeinated and available in medium or large.

Visit The Bagels in Garden City, NY for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Iced Flavored Coffee is rich and smooth over ice, with flavors such as banana nut, Dubai chocolate, and vanilla caramel.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular coffee options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the drink options we recommend most often.

Iced Flavored Coffee — This coffee is served over ice; choose a medium or large size, with optional flavors, sweeteners, and milk choices.
Flavored Coffee — Choose small or large, then optionally select French vanilla or hazelnut flavor and additions such as milk, sweetener, or black.
Iced Coffee — Choose a medium or large iced coffee, with optional milk, sweetener, or black preparation to suit your preference.
Iced Decaf — Decaffeinated coffee is served iced in a required medium or large size, with optional milk, sweetener, or black preparation.
Regular Coffee — Freshly brewed coffee comes in a required small or large size, with optional milk, non-dairy milk, and sweetener choices.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for coffee throughout the Garden City area. Order your coffee online for convenient pickup or delivery.