Skip to main content
Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels

Bakery in Garden City

Freshly baked bagels and sweet pastries are part of the bakery selection at The Bagels in Garden City, where you can order for pickup.

Order online

Bagels

Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels

$1.90+

A fresh hand-rolled bagel in a required choice of available varieties.

“This place is hands down the best bagel shop in Garden City. Unlike other most shops, this place actually hand rolls their bagels. You can even see the guy making bagels by their window. So the bagels are super fresh, moist, and just right.”

Pastries

Desserts

Cookies

$3.99

Freshly baked cookies come in several varieties.

“With a bakery on-site, this bagel and sandwich shop offers freshness daily. It carries a wide variety of drinks, more cream cheese versions than most places--including tofu cream cheese in various forms. Additionally, there are four to five varieties of lox available. Highly recommended.”

At the Heart of The Bagels

The Bagels offers bakery treats from soft, freshly baked bagels to toasted bagels topped with smoked salmon. Sweet pastries include fruit- or cheese-filled strudel and Danish with creamy cheese filling.

Freshly baked Muffins come in banana nut and pistachio flavors, while Cookies include chocolate chunk and oatmeal raisin options. Cinnamon Bun is a sweet, soft pastry with a cinnamon filling.

Visit The Bagels in Garden City for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. Crumb Cake has a moist, sweet base and a crunchy streusel topping, with caramel available alongside the plain flavor.

Frequently asked questions

What are your most popular bakery options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels — Select one hand-rolled bagel variety, with options ranging from savory garlic and multigrain to sweet blueberry and cinnamon raisin.
  • Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel — The spread is plain cream cheese, with optional bread choices including bagels, bialy, croissant, and ciabatta.
  • Flavored Croissant — This flaky, buttery pastry offers optional choices of almond croissant, chocolate, or regular croissant styles.
  • Strudel — This sweet pastry has a fruit-or-cheese filling; apple is listed as an available variety, not a guaranteed filling.
  • Lox Red Onion and Caper on a Bagel — This bagel is topped with smoked salmon, sharp red onion, and briny capers; toasting and bread types are available choices.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for bakery throughout the Garden City area. Order your bakery online for convenient pickup or delivery.