Sweet pastries and savory bagels fill the bakery offerings at The Bagels in Garden City, NY, with pickup available for your order.
Order onlineFresh Hand Rolled Bagels
$1.90+
Freshly baked, soft bagels with a required choice of bagel type.
“This place is hands down the best bagel shop in Garden City. Unlike other most shops, this place actually hand rolls their bagels. You can even see the guy making bagels by their window. So the bagels are super fresh, moist, and just right.”
Tofu Scallion Cc on a Bagel
$5.25
Scallion cream cheese and crispy tofu top a toasted bagel.
“With a bakery on-site, this bagel and sandwich shop offers freshness daily. It carries a wide variety of drinks, more cream cheese versions than most places--including tofu cream cheese in various forms. Additionally, there are four to five varieties of lox available. Highly recommended.”
Flagel
$2.50
A thin, flat toasted bagel spread with cream cheese.
“Great bagels especially their flagels.”
Nutella on a Bagel
$3.65
Nutella is spread over a bagel, with bread and toasting choices.
“Sweet staff, very attentive, they have nutella bagels! Wednesdays is buy 3 bagels and get one free!!”
Muffins
$4.50
Muffins come in flavors such as blueberry, pistachio, and banana nut.
“I had a great experience there the food was great also the muffins Were great , the staff were friendly and curtious definitely will be going back.”
Strudel
$3.50
Sweet pastry filled with fruit or cheese; apple is an optional filling.
“The combination of muffins and everything bagels with cream cheese offers a diverse range of tastes and textures. Whether enjoyed separately or together, these items provide a satisfying and enjoyable culinary experience. They cater to different preferences while maintaining high quality. Both the muffins and everything bagels with cream cheese receive a five-star rating due to their delicious flavors, satisfying textures, and overall enjoyable experience. They are highly recommended for a quick snack or a more substantial meal.”
Cookies
$3.99
Freshly baked cookies are available in several optional varieties.
“Just picked up a large bagel and pastry order for a breakfast on the go from The Bagels on Nassau Blvd, and as always, everything was perfect. The bagels are fresh, hand-pulled, and made right on site — you can really taste the difference. A special shoutout to Robert for the wonderful customer service. The entire team is always so kind, welcoming, and efficient, which makes every visit a great experience.”
Cupcake
$4.99
A sweet cupcake, with several flavor and style choices available.
“Best bagels and cupcakes right at this location ! They offer rye bagels which is so great and the caraway seeds on them is an added plus !”
The Bagels' bakery offerings include toasted bagels with smoked bacon, cheddar and cream cheese, fruit- or cheese-filled sweet pastries, and freshly baked ciabatta filled with cream cheese.
Muffins come freshly baked in flavors such as banana nut and pistachio. Cookies include chocolate chunk and oatmeal raisin options, while Crumb Cake is moist and sweet with a crunchy streusel topping.
Visit The Bagels in Garden City, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. The freshly baked Scone is a sweet pastry available in flavors including blueberry, chocolate chip and orange cranberry.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
