American Food in Garden City

Explore American food at The Bagels in Garden City, NY, with satisfying breakfast plates, bagels, and sandwiches available for pickup.

Order online

Bagels

Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels

$1.90+

Freshly baked, hand-rolled bagels come in a choice of flavors.

“Just picked up a large bagel and pastry order for a breakfast on the go from The Bagels on Nassau Blvd, and as always, everything was perfect. The bagels are fresh, hand-pulled, and made right on site — you can really taste the difference. A special shoutout to Robert for the wonderful customer service. The entire team is always so kind, welcoming, and efficient, which makes every visit a great experience.”

Ham Sandwich

$8.75

Thinly sliced ham fills a bagel, with optional toppings available.

Colorado Sandwich

$12.99

A sandwich with chicken cutlet, melted mozzarella, lettuce, tomato, and mayo.

The Philly Steak

$12.99

Steak sandwich layered with provolone and grilled onions.

Cream Cheese Spreads

Ciabatta Hero

$2.75

Freshly baked ciabatta filled with smooth cream cheese.

“surprise surprise the BEST bagels. breakfast puts IHOP to steppin. dont sleep the Hero’s Champ Style! Football Season coming. Thank you Rob for Excellent / Professional Service.”

Tofu Scallion Cc on a Bagel

$5.25

A bagel with scallion cream cheese and crispy tofu.

Tofu Cc on a Bagel

$5.25

Tofu and cream cheese are served together on a toasted bagel.

Bacon Cheddar Cc on a Bagel

$5.75

Smoked bacon and cheddar with cream cheese top a toasted bagel.

Breakfast

Double Egg

$5.25

Two eggs are prepared in your choice of four required styles.

French Toast

$8.75

Thick bread dipped in egg and served as a sweet breakfast.

Western Omelette

$9.99

Fluffy omelette filled with ham, pepper, onion, and cheese.

Spinach Omelette Platter

$12.25

Spinach omelette served with home fries and toast or a bagel.

Sandwiches

BLT

$6.75

Crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomato on toasted bread.

Chicken Deluxe

$12.99

Chicken cutlet sandwich with American cheese, bacon, and BBQ sauce.

The New Yorker

$15.25

Pastrami or corned beef with Swiss, coleslaw, and dressing.

Tex Mex Chicken

$12.99

Chipotle chicken, jalapeno pepper jack, bacon, and Cajun mayo fill this sandwich.

From the Kitchen at The Bagels

At The Bagels, you can explore American food spanning breakfast plates, omelettes, bagels with cream cheese, grilled choices, cold-cut sandwiches, and signature sandwich combinations.

Choose Grilled Cheese with melted cheese between bread, The Honey Dripper with honey turkey, muenster, bacon, and honey mustard, or Western Omelette with ham, pepper, onion, and cheese.

Visit The Bagels in Garden City, NY, for dine-in, arrange pickup when you are on the go, or choose delivery to enjoy your order wherever it suits you; select a bagel, breakfast plate, or sandwich.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular American food options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Double Egg — This breakfast includes two eggs, with fried, over easy, scrambled, or sunny-side-up preparation selected to order.
Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels — Select from Asiago, bialy, blueberry, egg, everything, garlic, multigrain, low carb, and other listed bagel varieties.
BLT — This sandwich combines bacon, lettuce, and tomato with toasted bread for a savory, crisp, and fresh bite.
French Toast — This sweet breakfast uses thick bread dipped in egg, with a required white or whole-wheat bread choice.
Western Omelette — This omelette combines ham, pepper, onion, and cheese, with optional bread, toppings, and breakfast additions available.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for american food throughout the Garden City area. Order your american food online for convenient pickup or delivery.