Sandwiches in Garden City

Bagel-based sandwiches and cheese-filled melts at The Bagels in Garden City, NY are available for pickup with your choice of bread.

Order online

Bagels

BLT

$6.75

Crisp bacon, lettuce, and tomato fill toasted bread in this sandwich.

“Delicious food, welcoming customer service, and lovely ambience. I love coming here and would recommend it to anyone looking for bagels, sandwiches, coffee, etc.”

Grilled Cheese

$7.50

Melted cheese sits between bread slices in this customizable sandwich.

“I’ve been coming here since my senior year of undergrad so about 2 years now. it’s always super good bagels, sandwiches, and coffee! i’m always bringing my friends too. friendly staff as well :)”

Signature Sandwiches

The Honey Dripper

$12.99

Honey turkey, melted Muenster, bacon, and honey mustard fill this sandwich.

“Wanted to give a shoutout to Morris. He made me the Honey Dripper sandwich on a sesame seed bagel for me today. It was one of the greatest sandwiches of my life. Go Morris!”

The Champ

$12.99

Ham, salami, provolone, lettuce, and tomato fill this sandwich.

“surprise surprise the BEST bagels. breakfast puts IHOP to steppin. dont sleep the Hero’s Champ Style! Football Season coming. Thank you Rob for Excellent / Professional Service.”

Deli

Pastrami Sandwich

$8.75

Thinly sliced pastrami served on a bagel; other bread styles are optional.

“Pastrami on roll salads . Food is. Fresh and delicious. Service is excellent.”

Oven Gold Turkey Sandwich

$8.75

Sliced Oven Gold turkey on a bagel, with optional customizations.

“I highly recommend. Everything is fresh. There is a large variety of cream cheeses, bagels and sandwiches. I love the iced coffee. The ice is made from coffee which doesn’t water down the drink! Service is excellent and staff is very friendly. Check it out!”

Fish

Tuna Salad

$8.75

Tuna mixed with greens, with bagel or roll formats available.

“We love The Bagels! The employees are so nice and friendly. The service is fast and accurate. Their bagels are delicious and the tuna is the best around!”

Lox Scallion Cc on a Bagel

$6.99

Smoked salmon, scallions, and cream cheese on a customizable bagel.

“With a bakery on-site, this bagel and sandwich shop offers freshness daily. It carries a wide variety of drinks, more cream cheese versions than most places--including tofu cream cheese in various forms. Additionally, there are four to five varieties of lox available. Highly recommended.”

Chicken

Chicken Salad

$8.75

Chicken salad with greens and customizable bread options.

“Great bagels and chicken salad too”

Chipotle Chicken Sandwich

$8.75

Spicy chicken breast with chipotle peppers, served as a sandwich.

Salads

Egg Salad

$7.75

Seasoned eggs are mixed into this classic egg salad.

Chipotle Chicken Salad

$8.99

Spicy chipotle chicken is mixed with fresh greens in this salad.

A Taste of The Bagels

At The Bagels, sandwiches include smoked salmon, scallions and cream cheese on a toasted bagel, tuna mixed with greens, and eggs with seasonings; bread choices include Asiago bagels and croissants.

The Honey Dripper pairs honey turkey with melted Muenster, bacon and honey mustard. Texan Melt has roast beef, bacon and melted mozzarella; The Philly Steak combines steak, provolone and grilled onions.

Visit The Bagels in Garden City, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Country Chicken Time pairs chicken salad with cranberries, walnuts, lettuce and tomato, with a 1/4 lb potato salad side available.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Just Bacon a Livin' — This sandwich combines mesquite turkey with melted cheddar and bacon, with optional bread, condiments, and deli sides.
BLT — Fresh lettuce and juicy tomato accompany crisp bacon, with optional bread styles, cheeses, and condiments available to customize it.
Chicken Salad — Freshly prepared chicken salad with greens can be ordered on customizable bread, with optional additions such as tomato, avocado, or pickles.
Pastrami Sandwich — Thinly sliced pastrami comes on a bagel, with other bread styles available to customize the sandwich.
Ham Sandwich — Thinly sliced ham is served on a bagel, with optional choices for bread type, toasting, cheese, condiments, and add-ons.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Garden City area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.