Skip to main content
Prosciutto Di Parma Sandwich

Sandwiches in Garden City

Explore a wide variety of sandwiches at The Bagels in Garden City, NY, available for pickup with your choice of bread and toppings.

Order online

Sandwiches to Try

Chicken Salad

$8.75

Fresh chicken salad with greens comes on a bagel or roll.

“Best bagels n chicken salad around”

BLT

From the Kitchen at The Bagels

The Bagels in Garden City, NY serves an extensive sandwiches menu, with options ranging from classic deli cold cuts to bold signature creations on your choice of bagel or roll.

Crowd-pleasing picks include the Pastrami Sandwich, The New Yorker, Roast Beef Sandwich, Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich, The Italian, and Wicked Chicken, each customizable with cheese, condiments, and add-ons.

Whether you stop in for dine-in, arrange pickup, or opt for delivery, Garden City, NY neighbors can enjoy The Bagels sandwiches any day of the week from 6:00 AM to 3:00 PM.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • BLT — This toasted sandwich layers bacon, lettuce, and tomato; bread style, cheese, and extra proteins can be customized.
  • Chicken Salad — Fresh chicken salad with greens is served on bread, with optional toppings including tomato, avocado, and pickles.
  • Black Forest — This sandwich combines Black Forest ham, cheddar, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise with customizable bread and sides.
  • Pastrami Sandwich — Thinly sliced pastrami fills a bagel sandwich, with optional toasting, cheese, toppings, condiments, or a deli-salad side.
  • Ham Sandwich — Choose optional bread styles, toasting, cheese, condiments, add-ons, or a side of coleslaw, macaroni salad, or potato salad.
Do you offer delivery and takeout?
Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Garden City area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.