Skip to main content
Pastrami Sandwich

Deli in Garden City

Savory sandwiches, cold cuts and salmon blends fill the deli offerings at The Bagels in Garden City, NY, available for pickup.

Order online

Cream Cheese Spreads

1/2 lb Lox Red Onion & Caper

$8.99

Half a pound of smoked salmon with red onion and capers.

“Our local school was hosting a mega event at the school and Robert, the manager, put our mind to ease with catering our brunch for almost 300 people. The communication was excellent and prompt and He was very accommodating with our specific menu. I highly recommend checking out The Bagels for any event or own personal craving of bagels. Best bagels in town and a huge selection of flavored cream cheeses. The salmon, caper and red onion is one of my top favorites. Store is very clean and enough seating to have breakfast/lunch there. Coffee is delicious too.”

Sandwiches

Deli Cold Cuts

Salads

Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich

Made with Care at The Bagels

The Bagels serves deli sandwiches, cold cuts, salads and cream cheese blends. You'll find smoked salmon with scallions, honey-and-maple turkey breast and Italian-style salami for sandwiches or snacking.

The New Yorker pairs pastrami or corned beef with Swiss and coleslaw. Cuban combines roast pork, ham and melted Swiss with pickles and chipotle mayo. Chicken Time layers chicken salad, bacon, lettuce and tomato.

Visit The Bagels in Garden City, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Tuna Salad mixes fresh tuna with greens; you can add avocado and choose an everything bagel or a croissant for your sandwich.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular deli options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Chicken Salad — Freshly prepared chicken salad with greens can be ordered on customizable bread, with optional additions such as tomato, avocado, or pickles.
  • Pastrami Sandwich — Thinly sliced pastrami comes on a bagel, with other bread styles available to customize the sandwich.
  • Ham Sandwich — Thinly sliced ham is served on a bagel, with optional choices for bread type, toasting, cheese, condiments, and add-ons.
  • The Americano — This sandwich layers roast beef and turkey with Swiss cheese, onion, lettuce, and tomato; bread type and toast level can be customized.
  • The New Yorker — Choose pastrami or corned beef with Swiss and coleslaw, then select Russian dressing or mustard and customize the bread.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for deli throughout the Garden City area. Order your deli online for convenient pickup or delivery.