Skip to main content
Pastrami Sandwich

Bagels in Garden City

Bagels with sweet cream cheese spreads and savory fillings are available at The Bagels in Garden City, NY, with pickup for your order.

Order online

Bagels to Try

Flagel

A thin, flat toasted bagel spread with cream cheese.

“Great bagels especially their flagels.”

Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels

Freshly baked, soft bagels with a required choice of bagel type.

“They have the most amazing bagels and so many varieties of cream cheeses .”

“Absolutely great place for fresh, tasty bagels! And much much more. But That OJ!!!!! oh my!!! The Beat!”

Specialty Bagels

Choose a bagel with rye, asiago, cheddar, jalapeño, Nutella, and more.

“Great food, nice people, great atmosphere. Rare fines for rye bagels!”

“Best bagels and cupcakes right at this location ! They offer rye bagels which is so great and the caraway seeds on them is an added plus !”

Flavored Cc with Bacon on a Bagel

$6.99

Smoked bacon and flavored cream cheese top a toasted bagel.

“Just picked up a large bagel and pastry order for a breakfast on the go from The Bagels on Nassau Blvd, and as always, everything was perfect. The bagels are fresh, hand-pulled, and made right on site — you can really taste the difference. A special shoutout to Robert for the wonderful customer service. The entire team is always so kind, welcoming, and efficient, which makes every visit a great experience.”

Ham Sandwich

$8.75

Thinly sliced ham served on a bagel, with optional customizations.

“We ordered a bunch of bagels for a birthday party and also had some from here a couple days before. They were just awesome. Super friendly just to order at the counter in person, and they threw in some extras too. Bagels, lox, schmear were all delicious, manager was super friendly. We’ll be back regularly!”

Peanut Butter on a Bagel

$3.65

Peanut butter is spread on a bagel, with toasting optional.

“My husband went here for the first time. Parking was no problem. He was very impressed when he walked in. The store was set up so nice and very clean. There were tables to sit and eat at. The staff was very helpful and the food in the show case looked delicious. He ordered bagels, cream cheese and some pastries. He got home and after eating it, said it was the best bagel he had ever had. Looks like this is going to be our new stop. I give them 5 stars.”

Sliced Lox on a Bagel

$12.99

Smoked salmon on a toasted bagel, with optional topping choices.

“We love this bagel place. Go there often not only for the bagels but their sandwiches and pastries as well. We just did a catering order this Easter. Bagel platter, pastry platter and a fruit platter and they delivered everything. Bagels and pastries were so fresh and incredibly delicious. Especially satisfied with their fruit platter which was fresh, and beautifully arranged. Prices were great and platters were very generous. Thank you again Roberto!!”

Tofu Cc on a Bagel

$5.25

Tofu and cream cheese top a bagel, with bread and toasting choices.

“Our local school was hosting a mega event at the school and Robert, the manager, put our mind to ease with catering our brunch for almost 300 people. The communication was excellent and prompt and He was very accommodating with our specific menu. I highly recommend checking out The Bagels for any event or own personal craving of bagels. Best bagels in town and a huge selection of flavored cream cheeses. The salmon, caper and red onion is one of my top favorites. Store is very clean and enough seating to have breakfast/lunch there. Coffee is delicious too.”

Honey Maple Turkey Sandwich

From the Kitchen at The Bagels

At The Bagels, bagels come topped with cream cheese and fresh strawberries, walnuts and raisins, or spicy jalapeño peppers. Other combinations pair smoked salmon with red onion and capers.

Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels are freshly baked and soft. Specialty Bagels include rye and prosciutto. Pastrami Sandwich puts thinly sliced pastrami on a bagel, with deli mustard available.

Visit us in Garden City, NY for pickup, dine-in, or delivery. The Jamaican pairs grilled chicken with Colby Jack cheese, avocado, chipotle mayo, and jerk sauce; a quarter-pound potato salad side is available.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular bagels options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

  • Fresh Hand Rolled Bagels — These soft, freshly baked bagels come with a required selection from several varieties, including everything, blueberry, and multigrain.
  • Plain Cream Cheese on a Bagel — A plain cream cheese spread tops a bagel, and you can choose the bread type and whether to have it toasted.
  • Butter on a Bagel — The bagel comes with butter spread across it, while bread type and toasted or untoasted preparation can be customized.
  • Low Fat Scallion Cc on a Bagel — Scallion cream cheese is spread on a bagel, with bread styles and toasted or untoasted preparation available.
  • Scallion Cc on a Bagel — Cream cheese with scallions is served on a bagel; choose the bread type and request toasted or untoasted preparation.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for bagels throughout the Garden City area. Order your bagels online for convenient pickup or delivery.
Order with AppOrder online